Private REITs vs. Public Non-Traded REITs: Tax Efficiency Comparison

 

A four-panel digital comic titled "Private vs. Public Non-Traded REITs: Tax Efficiency." Panel 1: A financial advisor says, “PRIVATE REITs offer custom tax outcomes,” while speaking to a businessman. Panel 2: The businessman thinks to himself, “PUBLIC NON-TRADED REITs are less flexible...” with dollar signs around him. Panel 3: The advisor holds a clipboard and says, “Consult a tax advisor about your REIT structure.” Panel 4: The businessman, now excited, raises his fist and declares, “I WANT THE MOST TAX EFFICIENCY!” with dollar symbols in the background.

Private REITs vs. Public Non-Traded REITs: Tax Efficiency Comparison

📌 Table of Contents

Overview of REIT Structures

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) allow investors to gain exposure to real estate income without owning physical property.

Two often-confused types are private REITs and public non-traded REITs (PNTRs).

While both avoid corporate-level taxation under IRS rules, their investor tax experience can differ significantly.

What Are Private REITs?

Private REITs are not registered with the SEC and are typically offered only to accredited investors.

They often have higher minimum investment requirements and may be part of direct-placement deals.

These REITs may provide greater flexibility in structuring income and distributions, which can be leveraged for tax efficiency.

What Are Public Non-Traded REITs?

Public Non-Traded REITs (PNTRs) are registered with the SEC but not listed on public exchanges.

They’re often sold through broker-dealers and offer limited liquidity—investors may need to hold for 5–7 years.

PNTRs must distribute at least 90% of their taxable income, and those distributions are generally taxed at ordinary income rates.

Tax Treatment Comparison

Both types pass through income to shareholders, avoiding corporate-level tax.

Private REITs may allow for more favorable distribution planning, including potential capital gains or return of capital components.

PNTR distributions are typically taxed as ordinary income unless otherwise specified.

Neither REIT type is inherently more "tax-advantaged," but private REITs can offer customization depending on structure and investor profile.

Which is More Tax-Efficient?

Private REITs often provide better tax efficiency for high-net-worth investors due to structured distributions and access to advanced tax planning tools.

PNTRs may be more accessible to retail investors but typically come with higher fees and less control over timing or character of distributions.

For investors in higher tax brackets, the flexibility of private REITs can lead to improved after-tax returns.

Conclusion

Choosing between private and public non-traded REITs depends on your income, access, liquidity needs, and tax strategy.

Private REITs are ideal for investors who prioritize custom tax outcomes, while PNTRs offer simpler access for passive investors.

Always consult with a tax advisor or financial planner before investing in any REIT structure.

🔗 Related Resources

Explore these expert references on REIT structures and tax implications:











Keywords: private REIT tax, non-traded REITs, real estate investment tax, REIT structure comparison, after-tax return REIT